Alex Garland’s ‘Men’: Stylish and Thought-Provoking

Harper (Jessie Buckley) is a woman recovering from the shock of seeing her husband James (Paapa Essiedu) fall off the roof of their flat, maybe or maybe not on purpose. She takes a trip to a quiet English countryside only to find that her man troubles are just beginning.

When a church has pagan imagery on display, it’s time to run fast and far

It’s easy to read the film as man-hating. Literally every male Harper sees, including her husband, is trying to control her, manipulate her, hurt her, fuck her. Even the friendly Geoffrey (Rory Kinnear) trips over himself in his insistence to be her knight in shining armor, to carry her bags, pay for her drinks, save her from randos in the yard. Her only allies are her gal pal Riley (Gayle Rankin) and a sympathetic female police officer (Sarah Twomey) who shows up once, never to return.

Really Harper has nothing to worry about, these men are just big babies

Buuuut you can also interpret the film as misogynistic. A lot of the buildup of tension in the film is based on the concept of widdle Harper alone in the big, sprawling wilderness, being menaced by a disturbing parade of male psychopaths, including a naked guy. Imagine a horror movie with those gender roles reversed, a man being stalked by a naked woman:

You don’t have to imagine it, because I made a poster!

Okay, not every man would react that way.

Most of the gripes about sexism come from towards the end, when Harper goes from refusing to be a victim, saying things like, “I will fucking cut you!”

Hers is bigger, pal.

to damsel in distress, lying in the road and trembling when somone she trusted turns out to be her enemy.

Whether or not you think it’s sexist, you can’t deny it’s beautifully shot

Honestly though, I don’t know how to parse the image system throughout that is, shall we say, distinctly feminine:

Vagina!
Vagina!
Vaaaaagina!

However, while I can see the movie from both perspectives, ultimately Harper’s dilemma seems very personal. She’s dealing with her particular grief and guilt, and her surroundings and interactions reflect that. There’s a dreamlike quality throughout, especially toward the climax. While I might have liked to see her turn into a stabby, badass action hero, that’s not her character arc.

The movie flitted in and out of my radar for a couple of years. I think I put it on my watchlist after seeing it was written and directed by Alex Garland, of whom I am a fan. When I told my sister Leslie I enjoyed it, she asked, “Was it scary or just weird?” I responded, “Well it’s A24 lol.” Which means that it’s a bit of both, but mostly the latter. Give it a look if you’re in the mood for something challenging but easy on the eyes.

Published by GhoulieJoe

I'm a mom who loves horror movies, the '80s, and the library. I write about the above three topics more than is healthy. I've got reviews, listicles, lil nonfiction pieces, and random bits of whutnot. I also included some pretentious as hell microfiction (don't worry, it's at the bottom). Because horror is life and vice versa.

9 thoughts on “Alex Garland’s ‘Men’: Stylish and Thought-Provoking

  1. This got good reviews a few years ago. Seemed like a minor hit. I’ve been meaning to check it out. Those posters are great. Us men can only dream of being stalked by a naked woman. Or man. You know what movie I really liked by A24? Something called The Lobster.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Oh, I’m glad. I just pick up bits here and there from iMDB and google while I’m looking for images. Thank you–the pictures section of my reviews is the most fun part. I loved The Lobster! So offbeat and surprising. Did you see The Killing of a Sacred Deer? Polar opposite, but same director and also has Colin Farrell.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Cool channel! I listened to three or four of your videos yesterday on my way home from work. If you really want to know, a few favorites I always recommend are Phantasm, Happy Birthday to Me, Basket Case, Sleepaway Camp, Demons, Hellraiser, and Puppet Master, for different reasons. Wes Craven’s The Serpent and the Rainbow doesn’t get talked about very much. Neither does Dust Devil. You’ve probably seen all those. A newer(ish) movie I keep coming back to is Exists (2014). It’s about a group of friends that encounters a Bigfoot at a cabin. Easily my favorite found-footage horror, by one of the guys who did Blair Witch.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Aw thank you! Seen Phantasm, Demons, Hellraiser, Puppet Master, The Serpent and the Rainbow. I don’t think I saw Exists; I know I saw Willow Creek and Happy Camp, which are also found footage Bigfoot movies released around the same time. I’ll check out the other ones, thank you!

        Like

Leave a comment

Is this your new site? Log in to activate admin features and dismiss this message
Log In